Looks like
Annie's getting ready to post her grades soon so I figured I'd get going too. Besides, I'm just killing time until Santa--the real one, not Schultzie Claus--to show up.
Eric Comrie: B
Perhaps my expectations were too high, I mean he is supposed to be the next goalie messiah. But at the same time, he's 16. Comrie is a behbeh. He didn't have the best start, probably nerves and adjusting to the WHL, but is starting to come around and put together some solid performances. I'm certainly not as nervous when I hear he's the starter, though he's still letting in some stinkers now and then. I'm glad he got any kinks worked out early so that the rest of the season will be smooth for he and Rimmer to divide the duties. I think Eric still has some learning to do, obviously, but he's going to be very very good and he's on the right track.
Riley Guenther: C
It happens every year, I struggle with what grade to give guys who haven't played a lot. So for Riley I went with a "C", which is average. He has only played in 10 games, has one assist. I do like his size, he is big and built like a Mack Truck. But not doughy or pudgy, seems just totally ripped. Or maybe that's just what image I have in my dirty little mind. He has a lot of potential, I haven't seen any huge glaring mistakes from him, just inexperience. The defensive depth of the Americans is a nice problem to have, especially for some like me who were worried before the season what the D corps would look like.
Sam Grist: A
Sam is playing so well, so smart. Last season it was a lot of silly penalties, but also some penalties where he just wasn't in control of his size. A guy that big has got to watch his elbows and whatnot. So far this season he has racked up some PIMs, 61 of them, but keep in mind that includes several fighting major and at least one ridiculous 10-minute misconduct in that game against Seattle before the Christmas break. Long story short, he's playing smarter. It also amazes me night in and night out how a guy that big skates so well, but he does. Additionally, Sam plays well enough for himself and to pick up any necessary slack from his rookie D partner, Plutnar.
Drydn Dow: A++++++++++
Srsly. I always always always knew he was a good defenseman. Always. No, he's not the biggest D-man on the ice, but he makes up for it with skill, speed, and vision. He plays smart and he plays well. Last season he got to some as forward and didn't disappoint which I think gave him confidence going into this season. That also gave the coaches a chance to see how versatile he can be. He and Derek Ryckman have logged a crapload of minutes and have been absolutely brilliant, they are able to compliment each other so well on the ice.
Derek Ryckman: A+
Speaking of Ryckman, he's been outstanding. As mentioned, he and Dow compliment each other and have been a stellar D pairing. It took a couple of games after being traded from Lethbridge to get his bearings and to really click. I won't lie, I was nervous those first couple games, afraid he'd be a bust. But lo and behold, I was quite happily mistaken. He skates well and isn't afraid to get his mitts dirty. Ryckman has contributed offensively with a goal and 4 assists and is sitting at a lovely +12.
Justin Hamonic: C
Same as Guenther, a "C" for average. Justin has played a few more games than Riley--13--and has done well. Nothing outstanding, nothing terrible. He has great size and decent speed. I think he has a lot of potential as well, but like Guenther will have to bide his time and be a good teammate while waiting his turn. Again, the defensive depth is a good problem to have. Since I'm a natural worrier, I do worry that Guenther's and Hamonic's development may be delayed with all the sitting in the stands, but I'm sure they'll be fine. They are playing some and practicing daily with one hell of a WHL team. How did this grade report mention Guenther so much? Sorry Justin, you're doing well babydoll.
Michal Plutnar: C+/B-
A bit above average. Michal has obviously had to adjust to the North American game and the pace of the WHL. But if you stop and remember he's only 17, he's doing pretty darn well. I think being paired with Sam has helped him because both are pretty much stay-at-home kind of players, which is fine. He's a rookie so there's often rookie mistakes, but overall he's playing well. If he continues in his development, he'll be in good shape. He skates well but could definitely use some cheeseburgers. Lots of them.
Lucas Nickles: C
Gotta go with another "average". The WHL stats page says he's been in 19 games, but it's not like he's played a ton of minutes in those 19. Nickles has played enough that I can't give him an incomplete. Actually, except for what seems to be a mandatory penalty every first shift he takes, he's played decent. He's a big enough kid and skates well, I think he's got a ton of potential. I thought he had a lot of potential when he got called up for a couple of games last season. I would love to see him get more playing time, I've said it once and I'll say it again, I'd love to have four GOOD lines to be able to roll out come playoff time. Giving these 4th line guys like Nickles only a shift or 3 per game isn't preparing them for when they may be needed further down the road. I realize Hughey-Shinny, Feser-Holland are the go-to guys, but if their legs can rest an extra shift or two come springtime, they could be more effective. Just my opinion.
Zachary Yuen: A
I guess I've been so dazzled by Dow and Ryckman that I have overlooked Yuen. Then again, I kind of know I can because he's that good. I know he's on the back end, getting work done. He's solid, reliable, and very talented. He's so damn smart with the puck and can skate so fluidly. It's just expected that he'll be outstanding. So it's not that I've overlooked him, it's that I haven't had to spend a lot of time observing him because I know what I'm getting from him, night in and night out. His work on the power play is brilliant and the pairing with Topping has worked out well for both of them. Oh, and he leads the team on +/- with a +23 right now. That's damn sexy.
Tyson Dallman: C
See everything I wrote for Nickles. Dolly's listed as playing 16 games, but again, not a ton of ice time in those 16. He's another one I'd like to see get more ice time to be prepared for ploffs. I wasn't kidding, just read what I said about Nickles and apply it to Dallman.
Malte Stromwall: B
Oh Malte, you and your adorable little button nose. I think it's been a tough adjustment for him coming from Sweden where he was a super-sniper scoring machine (or something close to it). In North America, it's a grittier game, gotta do work son. And he does. Unlike some Don Cherry stereotyped Euro, Malte is willing to get in the corners and fight for the puck. He's been frustrated by his lack of scoring, but his all-around game has improved. Oh and he's only 17. Personally I love watching him play. You can just tell he's some tiger that is about to be unleashed. Ok, maybe not quite like that, but he's super talented. He's got a passion for the game and pushes himself hard to do well.
Adam Hughesman: A
Obviously. Twenty-three goals, 36 assists. He and Shinnimin have the best chemistry in the league (at least I think so) and just keep rolling on. At times it amazes me how he has so many points because it seems like he's never moving his feet. Maybe it's relative since he's on the ice with Shinny who skates speedy circles around everyone. I also know Adam IS moving his feet because his skating is better than it has been. No more cement skates. But still, seems like he's just standing at the blue line waiting to cherry pick all the time. Oh well, he's not, he's scoring mad goals and that's damn sexy.
Mason Wilgosh: A
Mason is captain for a reason. Probably for many reasons, actually. But most of all for his spectacular work ethic. He's skating shifts, he's killing penalties, he's doing gritty work in the corners, he's covering the back end if need be. Talk about a utilitarian type of player. He leads by example and I'm not sure anyone else kills penalties quite like him. Ok, maybe Feser on that too, but still. A total defenseive forward type player. He's not the biggest guy and he's not going to make a ton of flashy plays, but he gets it done.
Jordan Messier: B-
Oh Big Mess. He missed the first couple games with concussion or upper-body injury or whatever the hell it was and it then took him awhile to get his timing right. He's trying to be a tough guy with a bunch of fights under his belt, but it's not exactly what I'd like to see his role being. Is he ever going to be a super-sniper goal scorer like I'd always hoped? It's not looking like it, and that's ok. There's a need for a guy to do work along the boards and create havoc for the opposition. I wish he wouldn't fight. I worry about his noggin and his history of concussions. He skates ok, though he often appears sort of clumsy and awkward. He's always just missing the pass or the net or whatever, always so close, but not quite there. I adore the kid, I mean seriously, he's got more personality in his pinky than I'll ever have, but unfortunately that doesn't translate into a superb hockey star.
Lukas Walter:
He's a nice young man, I sat with him at the Booster Club dinner. Beyond that, we all know how I feel and it's Christmas Eve and I'm going to stick with the old adage that if you don't have anything nice to say, don't say anything at all.
Marcus Messier: B+
Now Li'l Mess, that's another story (from his big bro). He's been outstanding. He doesn't get a shitload of ice time, but he makes it count when he does. He is fast and skilled. He's not afraid to get in the corners and fight for the puck. Tenacious is a good word to describe his play. Marcus is at that age/point where he's going to sit out a few games to make room for guys like Dallman and Nickles, but he's also missed a few with injury and a short suspension. But he's been consistent and has really progressed well.
Justin Feser: A
Offense. Defense. Penalty kill. Power play. Face-offs. Blocking shots. Reliable, consistent, utilitarian. I could go on and on, but you get the point. He's really good--at everything. Hell, he could probably play goalie if need be. I certainly wouldn't put it past him. Justin has quietly amassed 17 goals, same as Shinny. He's got a stellar work ethic and logs a crapload of minutes.
Brendan Shinnimin: A
Shinny started out slow, well, slow for Shinny. The goals weren't coming and you could tell he was frustrated. He is a fiercely competitive kid and very passionate about the game. Anyone who has watched him play the last couple years knew the goals would come, and sure enough, they have. He and Hughey have got into quite the rhythm and are steamrolling right to the net. If there was skills competition still (I need to seriously start campaigning for that to happen) he'd easily win fastest skater, hands down. He skates circles around the competition--literally, I've seen him do it. If he can't go around, he'll go right through. Shinny still gets worked over by bigger guys night after night, but he sticks with it and doesn't let it wear him down. He'll be damned if anyone is going to get in his way, that's for sure.
Mitch Topping: A
I don't recall what price Bob paid to get Mitch, but it was worth it. Totally worth it. He and Yuen compliment each other and have been awesome. Mitch is a great skater and both he and Yuen are not the stay-at-home types and can (and will) join the rush and bust the net if they see the opening. Mitch doesn't get as much power play time as his D partner since coach tends to go with 4 forwards and 1 D, but I'm not worried. He's only 18 so we'll get to watch his awesome play--and sexy face-- for a couple more seasons, which is exciting.
Brian Williams: A
WOWZA. I mean, this kid. For real. B-Dubs is really good. He may say it was a tough transition to the WHL, but I bet no one but him noticed. He played well from the start. He is a really fast and fluid skater and he's even been given responsibility on the power play. Brian isn't the biggest guy at all, and often gets pushed off the puck, but theoretically with age he'll bulk up and that will happen less. The kid is only 16 for God's sake. I am really really really excited to watch him develop over the next couple of seasons, it's going to be fun.
Connor Rankin: A
Oh, and this kid. Rankin certainly has not suffered any kind of sophomore slump. And boy is he fun to watch. Personally, I'm not sure he's the best (as in biggest) guy to park in front of the goalie when Shinny and Hughey are in scoring mode, Neal Prokop was great at that. Connor is a bit small for that role, but he does it anyways, taking all the abuse that comes with being in that spot. He does well on the Shinny-Hughey line, but it'd be hard not to, really.
------------
It's now Christmas, I'll finish the last 3 I didn't get to before church service last night. Oh, and
Annie's grades are up.
Ty Rimmer: A
Naturally I was distraught at the loss of Drew Owsley to Prince George so I wanted nothing to do with Rimmer. I wanted nothing to do with an unproven backup goalie. While I still miss Drew terribly, Rimmer has taken the bull by the horns and proven that yep, he's a damn good goalie. He leads the league in save percent at .929 which is as sexy as his face. He's done well in the mentoring role for Comrie and has been a great teammate as he and the youngster split games.
Nate MacMaster: A
Nate has my early vote for Unsung Hero. He's very utilitarian. He can take face-offs, he can kill penalties, he scores some goals here and there, and will drop the gloves if necessary. MixMaster isn't the super flashy goal-scoring type, he's a lunch-pail kind of player and those are vital. He sat several games with injury but has bounced back quite well.
Patrick Holland: A
When I think of all-around complete player, I think of Holland. He quietly goes about getting the job done--and does it well. He's a fantastic skater and has tremendous vision. The work he does with Feser is remarkable, just a pleasure to watch. Calgary Flames aren't going to be very disappointed in Holly I don't think. Annie says he has a slow start, and I guess if you're expecting him to score a ton of goals then sure. But in my opinion, and it is just mine, really complete all-around players don't necessarily score a lot, but they do all the little things besides just scoring. And that's Patrick. Don't get me wrong, I'd love him to get a shitload of goals, but I'm just so impressed with his overall game and talent, I live with not a gazillion goals from him.
Merry Christmas errbuddy!!